Should We Drink Whey Protein With Water Or Milk?

The answer depends on whether you should drink whey protein with water or milk depends on what will be best for your body’s needs. Drinking your whey protein shake with water or milk should not just be about preferences but also should support your fitness goals. There are certain advantages when mixing whey protein with water compared to using whey protein with milk. We will take a look into the different areas of consideration before you decide to mix your favorite whey protein with either milk or water.

Key Takeaways:

Whey protein with water is the better option if you are looking to lose weight. If you want to gain bulkier muscle, whey protein with milk is a better option while if you want lean muscles, water should be your go-to option. You should also consider your lactose intolerance and taste when deciding which liquid to mix your whey protein with.


Whey Protein With Milk or Water: Advantages and Disadvantages

Whey Protein With Milk or Water: Advantages and Disadvantages

The first areas that we’re going to take a look into when you consume protein with water or milk are the advantages and disadvantages. See below for the advantages and disadvantages when you mix whey protein powder with milk or water:

Whey Protein with Milk Advantages

Here are the advantages when you mix whey protein with milk:

  • Keeps you full for a longer period curbing hunger pangs.
  • Better texture and taste for your protein shake. Can even mask the taste of your whey protein.
  • With extra carbs that give energy for your workout.
  • Adds additional protein for you to achieve your daily protein goal.

Whey Protein with Milk Disadvantages

Here are the disadvantages when you mix whey protein with milk:

  • Consuming whey protein with milk adds to the calorie intake in your protein shakes.
  • Not for people with lactose intolerance.
  • If you plan to lose weight through calorie deficit, milk adds calories and may cause you to gain weight instead.
  • Additional mixing and preparation time with mixing milk.

Whey Protein with Water Advantages

Here are the advantages when you mix whey protein with water:

  • Promotes quick protein digestion.
  • No additional calories and helps you to lose weight better than milk.
  • Suitable option for people with lactose intolerance.
  • Helps build lean muscle mass.
  • With a neutral taste that won’t affect the taste of your flavored whey.

Whey Protein with Water Disadvantages

Here are the disadvantages when you mix whey protein with water:

  • Does not help improve the taste of unflavored whey protein powder.
  • Water has no nutritional value.
  • You might feel hunger pangs sooner than when you mix whey protein with milk.

Mixing Whey Protein Powder With Milk or Water: Considerations

Mixing Whey Protein Powder With Milk or Water: Considerations

Now that we have looked at the advantages and disadvantages, we will continue by taking a look into the different areas of consideration before you decide to mix whey protein with either milk or water. These include your fitness goals, dietary restrictions, and of course, taste preferences.

Personal Fitness Goals

Your fitness goals should be one of the main considerations when you decide if you want to mix whey protein with milk or water. If your goal is general fitness, then it does not matter whether you mix whey protein with milk or water. You will still be able to achieve your fitness goals as long as you are getting the recommended daily amount of protein intake and advisable protein requirement.

However, if your goal is to build lean muscle mass, then you should consider mixing whey protein with water instead of milk. This is because whey protein is quickly absorbed by the body when mixed with water and this helps to build muscle mass on the leaner side. As your body develops leaner muscles, it becomes deficient in amino acids. The deficiency promotes quick absorption of protein supply needed by the body for faster recovery.

If your goal is for bulkier muscles or to gain muscle mass, then mixing with milk is the better option because milk has extra carbohydrates and more protein that help in building muscles. Milk is made from 20 percent casein protein and 80 percent whey protein. The extra protein that you get from whole milk helps your muscles gain mass.

Dietary Restrictions

Another consideration when you consume whey protein with either milk or water is whether you have any dietary restrictions. If you are lactose intolerant, then you will not be able to mix whey protein with milk. In this case, you will have to mix whey with water instead.

Weight Loss

If you are trying to lose weight, you should also mix whey protein with water instead of milk. This is because milk adds additional calories to your protein shake which can hinder losing weight with the additional calorie intake. Water on the other hand does not contain additional calories and therefore mixing with water is a better option for those who are looking to reduce calories to avoid gaining weight.

Post Workout

For your post-workout shake, blending whey proteins with water is recommended because it helps to rehydrate and replenish your body with the electrolytes it has lost during your workout. Water also helps deliver the protein that your muscles need for recovery quickly.

Milk is also a good post-workout drink because it contains carbohydrates and proteins that help to rebuild and repair muscles. When mixed with whey protein, the protein in milk coagulates and help protein stay long thus bringing this constant release of amino acids.

Taste Preferences

Last but not least, your taste preferences should be taken into account when deciding whether to mix whey protein with water or milk. There is flavored whey protein that can mask that unwanted whey protein taste but sometimes it’s not enough and milk can greatly improve the taste of your protein shake.


Conclusion: Should you Drink Whey Protein or Water

Consuming whey protein with either water or milk is a good option to get the necessary amazing protein amount your body needs. Both have their advantages, disadvantages, and considerations. If you want to build bulkier muscles then milk is the best option while water would be a great choice if you want to have lean muscle mass and not gain weight.

The other things to consider include if you’re lactose intolerant you should avoid milk and if you want to have a better tasting workout shake milk is the better option. Water with whey protein is recommended if you want to lose weight.

We hope that this article helps you decide what the best option for you is.

Share on:

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER!
Expert tips, smart reads, exclusive discounts, and more.

Wishlist 0
Continue Shopping